New York Pizza Aspen

Our counter-serve spot at 409 E Hyman Ave delivers that classic New York thin crust right here in Aspen. We keep things unassuming and authentic, focusing on what matters: huge, perfectly foldable slices served on simple paper plates. Grab a quick lunch or settle in for dinner with our full lineup of slices, whole pizzas, fresh salads, hearty sandwiches, and crispy wings. We also pour a selection of beer and wine to pair with your meal. Open seven days a week, we offer a casual vibe that feels like a real NYC joint. Our dough is deliciously thin, and our pepperoni and mushroom toppings are consistently popular among locals who appreciate the bang-for-your-buck pricing. We serve multiple locations across the Western Slope, including spots in Carbondale and Basalt, but this Aspen location remains our home base for fast service and a friendly atmosphere. Come by for the pizza, stay for the no-frills charm.