Weiser Rejects $17 Million Federal Scholarship Program
Incoming Governor Phil Weiser rejected a federal scholarship program offering $17 million in private funding, clashing with Jared Polis and teacher unions over voucher definitions.

Governor Jared Polis called it. He said governors "would be crazy not to" opt in.
Phil Weiser disagrees. The incoming governor is a "firm no." He called anyone supporting the program "naive or misleading."
The Colorado Sun published an opinion piece Tuesday laying out why Weiser’s stance makes no sense. The federal scholarship tax credit starts in 2027. It offers a dollar-for-dollar credit to individuals who donate up to $1,700. Married couples filing jointly can claim up to $3,400.
Those donations go to scholarship organizations. The organizations then fund private-school tuition or public-school tutoring.
Colorado was among the first states to opt in. Polis signed the executive order in December. He became the first Democrat to do so. Since then, only one other Democratic governor joined via executive action: New York’s Kathy Hochul.
Thirty-two states are now in the program.
The math is simple. Education Reform Now says if just 1% of Colorado tax filers donate, kids could receive more than $17 million in scholarships. That is real money for families who otherwise have no access to private education or extra tutoring support.
Weiser wants out. The piece argues he is chasing political points, not policy results. The tax credit comes from the "One Big, Beautiful Bill." Weiser has built his identity on suing the Trump administration. Opposing the president’s signature bill earns cheap applause from partisan base voters.
Then there are the teacher unions. The piece notes that Weiser’s hyperbole about "privatization of public schools" curries favor with union executives like Randi Weingarten and Becky Pringle. They have encouraged states to opt out of what they call the "voucher scam."
But Weiser is a fan of vouchers. His education plank promotes universal preschool. Colorado sends money to private providers, many of which are faith-based. Last year, nearly 80 faith-based providers received about $9.5 million to serve more than 2,000 families.
Universal preschool is a voucher program by definition. The piece says Weiser can change its author’s mind, but the logic holds up.
The federal program does not use public funding for the scholarships themselves. Tax-credit scholarships run on private money. No public coffer gets raided. The federal government simply allows donors to reduce their tax liability by the amount they donate.
Critics will cry about "lost" revenue. The piece calls that logic ridiculous. Americans claim dozens of tax credits every year. Those credits "cost" the government hundreds of billions in reduced revenue, yet nobody calls them a crisis.
The piece ends on a dry note about the cognitive dissonance Weiser will have to manage. He opposes "school vouchers" but supports a state-funded universal preschool system that functions exactly like one.
Weiser takes office in January. The federal program kicks in 2027. He has time to change his mind, but the piece suggests he won’t. He will stick with "firm no" because it is easier than explaining why a state-funded preschool voucher is okay, but a federal tax-credit scholarship is not.
Read that again.
The short version: Polis opted in. Hochul opted in. Thirty-two states are in. Weiser is out. The program funds scholarships with private donations, not state taxes. And the incoming governor thinks that is a problem.
The piece calls Weiser "Cuckoo for Cocoa Puffs." Sticks and stones may break bones, but they won’t hurt a program that helps millions of kids. The real question is whether Weiser will let political theater override the $17 million in scholarships that could land on Western Slope kids’ desks.
He has until 2027 to figure that out.
Keep up with the Western Slope
The day's Western Slope news, one email each morning. Free.


