Garfield County Rejects 30-Day Lease for Proposed Aviation School
Garfield County commissioners voted to deny a 30-day lease for a proposed aviation charter school, citing severe structural issues in the former NAPA building.

Rifle —Judy Branberg wants to build a school by the runway. Her husband, Barry, wants to start with 50 kids in a leaking warehouse. The Garfield County commissioners said no.
On Monday, Nov. 9, the county board voted to reject a request from the proposed Garfield County School of Innovation. The school hoped to lease the former NAPA Auto Parts building at 949 Railroad Ave. in Rifle for 30 days. They needed that month to figure out if they could make the building work as a temporary home while they chased a permanent site near the Rifle Garfield County Airport.
The short version: The building is falling apart. And it’s expensive to fix.
Commissioner Mike Samson was the only one who wanted to give the Branbergs a chance. He voted in favor of the 30-day window. The other two commissioners opposed it. That ended the request before it started.
“I’m skeptical, but I’m willing to say, you know, give them a month, research it out,” Samson told the Post Independent. “See if you can do it. See if it’s possible with the money that you can do it and make it work.”
Samson is the outlier here. He’s not alone in his skepticism, though. The county officials who presented the case against the lease had a long list of problems to read into the record.
The building, purchased by the county in late 2018 or early 2019, has water damage from roof leaks. The insulation is saturated. Ceiling and floor tiles contain potential asbestos. The concrete floor has cracks. The foundation has significant concerns. None of the four bathrooms meet Americans with Disabilities Act requirements.
That’s a lot of "potential" and "significant" for a 10,000-square-foot space.
Barry Branberg tried to pivot. He told the commissioners the organization could use the building for a smaller program, not a full charter school launch. He suggested serving about 50 students through an innovation center or a homeschool enrichment program. The plan involved community donations and volunteer labor to patch things up.
It’s a bold pitch for a building the county already bought with the intention of demolishing. The land is slated to be incorporated into the Garfield County Fairgrounds campus. You don’t spend money fixing a building you plan to knock down unless the alternative is worse.
The Branbergs aren’t new to this game. Barry previously served as president and business manager at STEM School Highlands Ranch. Judy told the commissioners their long-term goal is a school near the airport, focused on aviation education. They have a signed letter of intent for approximately 70 acres in that area.
They submitted their charter school application to the Garfield Re-2 school board on Sept. 30. The district asked for more information, including a signed letter of intent for a facility. That request triggered the conversation about the Railroad Ave. building.
All three commissioners expressed support for the school’s concept. STEM and aviation education is a strong draw in this valley. But backing the idea didn’t translate to backing the location.
The building is a liability. The county knows it. The Branbergs know it too, which is why they’re talking about volunteer labor and donations to fix a structure that’s already failing.
The 30-day window is gone. The building stays empty, or at least it stays in the county’s hands while they plan its demolition. The Branbergs still have their 70 acres by the airport. But they don’t have a classroom yet.
The Post Independent reported that the rejection effectively ends the request to use the former NAPA building. The school’s founders now have a gap between their application and their permanent site. They need to bridge it without the county’s help.
Whether they can do that with donations and volunteer sweat is a question only time will answer. But the commissioners have already voted on the building’s fate. It’s not a school. It’s a demolition site waiting to happen.
Keep up with Rifle
The day's Western Slope news, one email each morning. Free.





