Skip to main content

High Wind Warning · Weather · Grand County · 22m ago

Details

The coin flip was a small, metallic gesture, but it carried the weight of a decade of institutional inertia

The coin flip was a small, metallic gesture, but it carried the weight of a decade of institutional inertia. It wasn’t a decision; it was a performance of indecision, a way to stay in the middle while the ground shifted…

Published Nov 18, 2026 · 6:07 AM2 min read
The coin flip was a small, metallic gesture, but it carried the weight of a decade of institutional inertia
Image source: Mike Littwin

The coin flip was a small, metallic gesture, but it carried the weight of a decade of institutional inertia. It wasn’t a decision; it was a performance of indecision, a way to stay in the middle while the ground shifted beneath the feet of the entire Democratic caucus.

That gesture belongs to John Hickenlooper, the newly reelected governor of Colorado, a man who embodies the establishment sensibility that has long defined the party’s leadership. When pressed by reporters on whether he would back Chuck Schumer or Chris Van Hollen for the role of Senate majority leader, Hickenlooper didn’t offer a manifesto or a policy platform. Instead, he mimed a coin flip, a visual shorthand for the genuine uncertainty that now pervades the party. He pointedly did not take the opportunity to stand with Schumer, who has held the gavel for ten years and was widely expected to keep it.

This hesitation is the story. As Mike Littwin noted in the Colorado Sun, if you’re surprised that Schumer is in danger, you’re not alone. The polls favor Van Hollen, but polls tell us almost nothing about the actual mechanics of the vote. The real contest will happen in December, behind closed doors, on a secret ballot. It is old-line politics, the kind where even the NSA might struggle to listen in.

The stakes are higher than just a leadership change. The voters asked for change, and whatever else Schumer is, he is not change. The fact that Democrats haven’t mounted an open challenge to their own leadership in decades is itself a sign of stagnation. Now, the new cohort of senators — those who won their seats in the wave election — are being forced to choose. Only two of the new progressives, Abdul El-Sayed of Michigan and Peggy Flanagan of Minnesota, have explicitly backed Van Hollen. But many of the others ran on anti-Schumer platforms.

Hickenlooper tried to frame the challenge as a betrayal of the team effort that flipped the Senate. “Leave it to the Democrats that we flip nine seats, and the person who actually helps put it all together and do all that, and all of a sudden, there’s a revolt,” he said. But the revolt is already here. Ken Salazar, the former Colorado senator and establishmentarian, has publicly sided with Van Hollen, calling Schumer “out of touch.” If Schumer loses the loyalty of moderates like Hickenlooper, his survival becomes questionable.

The silence in the caucus is loud. Behind closed doors, the secret ballot will decide not just who leads, but who survives. The coin is still in the air, spinning against the backdrop of a party that finally decided to look in the mirror.

The Morning Briefing

Keep up with the Western Slope

The day's Western Slope news, one email each morning. Free.