Skip to main content

US-160E closed · Road · Archuleta County · 10m ago

Details

Vail Daily Rates New Scrooge Film Two Stars

Vail Daily’s Movie Guru rates the new Scrooge adaptation two stars for tonal confusion while praising Godzilla Minus Zero as a top-tier sequel dealing with post-war trauma.

Published Nov 17, 2026 · 7:50 AM3 min read
Vail Daily Rates New Scrooge Film Two Stars
Image source: Head to Charles Dickens' London to experience "Ebenezer" and his supernatural journey to his past, present and future. Paramount/Courtesy photo

Aspen —The Vail Daily’s Movie Guru drops a verdict that might sting a bit for fans of the holiday season: “Ebenezer” is, quite literally, a Christmas movie in a Halloween costume.

If you’ve been waiting for a fresh spin on Dickens’ classic, you might be disappointed. Despite trailers promising an “untold” version, the film settles into a straightforward adaptation wrapped in Gothic horror window dressing. It’s a strange hybrid. At times, it feels like it wants to be a proper ghost story, complete with dark shadows and eerie tones, but then it dissolves under the weight of a Disney-esque Victorian Christmas card aesthetic. The result is a film that struggles to decide what it actually is.

Johnny Depp takes on the role of Scrooge, and he is arguably the adaptation’s biggest selling point. Whether you buy into it depends entirely on how much you already like Depp. His performance is highly stylized and somewhat cartoonish. The review notes that he is often the least interesting thing on screen, particularly in scenes with Ian McKellen. McKellen’s presence is described as tragic in a different way; he would have been such a fantastic Scrooge himself, making his supporting role a missed opportunity.

However, the cast shines in other areas. Sam Claflin as Fred and Arthur Conti as the young Scrooge are highlighted as standout performances in the film’s sentimental moments. In the Gothic horror segments, Andrea Riseborough and Tramell Tillman deliver a fantastic take on the Ghosts of Christmas Past and Present. It’s also nice to see Rupert Grint as Bob Cratchit, though the reviewer wishes they had let him do more.

Ultimately, “Ebenezer” is graded two stars out of four. It’s a perfectly fine adaptation, but the tragedy is that it stops itself from being anything special. It’s worth the drive if you’re a Depp fan, but if you look closely, the rough edges show.

The Giant Returns

On the other side of the spectrum, “Godzilla Minus Zero” is hailed as easily one of the top Godzilla movies of all time. It’s a massive follow-up to 2023’s “Godzilla Minus One,” and it’s a larger movie in every way. The scope of the action is bigger, and the quality is higher. But it also tries to address a wider range of Japanese post-WWII trauma.

The plot kicks off with characters still recovering from Hiroshima and Godzilla’s previous attack. Before they can catch their breath, a new Kaiju arrives from space, terrorizing Japan. Scientists are scrambling to stop it, but the invading Americans are more interested in how to weaponize it. When all else fails, the only hope left is Godzilla himself.

The movie delivers excellent fights and highly emotional moments. However, the wider view means it loses some of the tight focus of the last film. Some critics have felt the emotional beats are overwrought, but the review suggests they are dramatic enough to resonate. It builds beautifully on its predecessor, though it might have a harder time standing completely on its own.

The contrast between these two films is stark. One is a holiday staple dressed in spooky clothes, the other is a giant monster movie dealing with real-world pain. Both are in theaters now. You can feel the difference in tone the moment you sit down. One smells like pine needles and old books; the other smells like ozone and wet concrete. Which one do you want to watch? That’s the question.

The Morning Briefing

Keep up with Aspen

The day's Western Slope news, one email each morning. Free.